Saturday, January 24, 2026

What James Stirling and Bill McCartney agree on

On their Facebooks, Bill McCartney and James Stirling mutually subscribed to the following:
James Stirling and I had a productive conversation over beer and pizza between friends who see some of the world differently.
As the conversation unfolded it was interesting how much we actually agree on while beginning to understand each other’s perspectives.
Since we only know what we have been told by talking heads and internet chatter, we realized that neither of us knew the truth about some of our sticking points. So, we agreed to research/find the truth about whether ICE was breaking into homes and arresting people without legal authority and if illegals are being deported without due process.
Our elected officials, churches and other organizations don't appear to want to do anything to help heal our country’s divisions so, as it almost always is, it comes down to individuals to create a positive change among our circle of friends, communities, country....
We challenge everyone who reads this to have a talk, coupled with actually listening with someone you know who has a different political perspective. Find out what you agree and disagree on, then work to embrace the similarities while understanding the differences.
You too may be able to bring the temperature down between the two of you and improve your quality of life and for those you know and love. Please let us know if you accepted this challenge and how it turned out.

I wish to flesh out with Bill and James the things they agree on, and I will ask them here and on their Facebooks to try to do this. As this proceeds, I will record here what transpires. [to be continued]

Sunday, January 18, 2026

Robert Reich - Everyone with authority must speak out now

Email to Auburn University President Christopher Roberts
From: Rob Shattuck <rdshatt@aol.com>
To: president@auburn.edu <president@auburn.edu>
Cc: boles@auburn.edu <boles@auburn.edu>; editor@theplainsman.com <editor@theplainsman.com>; social@theplainsman.com <social@theplainsman.com>; ejr0030@auburn.edu <ejr0030@auburn.edu>; amm0357@auburn.edu <amm0357@auburn.edu>; lcm0061@auburn.edu <lcm0061@auburn.edu>; tstacy@aptv.org <tstacy@aptv.org>; Brian Lyman <blyman@alabamareflector.com>; yaffee@yellowhammernews.com <yaffee@yellowhammernews.com>; jmoon@alreporter.com <jmoon@alreporter.com>; Dale Jackson <dale@yellowhammernews.com>; rscott@aptv.org <rscott@aptv.org>; jsharp@al.com <jsharp@al.com>; blyman@gannett.com <blyman@gannett.com>; sbritt@alreporter.com <sbritt@alreporter.com>; bbritt@alreporter.com <bbritt@alreporter.com>; johnaarchibald@gmail.com <johnaarchibald@gmail.com>
Sent: Sunday, January 18, 2026 at 07:12:51 AM CST
Subject: Robert Reich - Everyone with authority must speak out now
Dear Auburn University President Roberts:
I am sending this email as a first email to try to carry out in Alabama the plea of Robert Reich (Professor, former Secretary of Labor, Co-founder Inequality Media, 4.8M followers on Facebook) that is posted at Robert Reich - Everyone with authority must speak out now against... | Facebook.
Robert Reich's plea is this:
"Everyone with authority must speak out now against Trump's depravity and lawlessness. Every elected official, university, professional association, charity, and foundation head. Every CEO. Every religious leader. If they don't, history will condemn their cowardice."
I have previously sent you emails (see Citizens Acting to End the Trump Presidency: Alabama debates what Eric Trump says about his father), and I am picking you as a first person of authority in Alabama to ask that you please speak out now against Trump's depravity and lawlessness.
Thank you very much.
Sincerely,
Rob Shattuck
Mountain Brook

Email to University of Alabama President Peter J. Mohler the Alabama State Bar Executive Council
From: Rob Shattuck <rdshatt@aol.com>
To: president@ua.edu <president@ua.edu>
Cc: lasikes@ua.edu <lasikes@ua.edu>; fhelmsing@joneswalker.com <fhelmsing@joneswalker.com>; jeff@rbmattorneys.com <jeff@rbmattorneys.com>; terri.lovell@alabar.org <terri.lovell@alabar.org>; jana@janagarner.com <jana@janagarner.com>; rbell@maynardnexsen.com <rbell@maynardnexsen.com>; jc@strengthconnally.com <jc@strengthconnally.com>; wlee4@llln-law.com <wlee4@llln-law.com>; gparker@bradley.com <gparker@bradley.com>; roman.shaul@alabar.org <roman.shaul@alabar.org>; cbutler@dfhlaw.com <cbutler@dfhlaw.com>; ttp@manleytraegerlaw.com <ttp@manleytraegerlaw.com>; Devan@thebyrdfirm.com <devan@thebyrdfirm.com>; "devan@thebyrdfirm.com" <devan@thebyrdfirm.com>; chad.coker@alabar.org <chad.coker@alabar.org>
Sent: Monday, January 19, 2026 at 05:04:37 AM CST
Subject: Robert Reich - Everyone with authority must speak out now
Dear University of Alabama President Mohler:
I am sending this email as part of trying to carry out in Alabama the plea of Robert Reich (Professor, former Secretary of Labor, Co-founder Inequality Media, 4.8M followers on Facebook) that is posted at Robert Reich - Everyone with authority must speak out now against... | Facebook.
Robert Reich's plea is this:
"Everyone with authority must speak out now against Trump's depravity and lawlessness. Every elected official, university, professional association, charity, and foundation head. Every CEO. Every religious leader. If they don't, history will condemn their cowardice."
Yesterday I sent a first email to Auburn University President Christopher Roberts, which email is posted at Citizens Acting to End the Trump Presidency: Robert Reich - Everyone with authority must speak out now.
This email to you is doing "double duty" by means of my copying on this email the members of the Alabama State Bar Executive Council.
Please, may you, as a person of authority rooted in the educational field in Alabama, and the members of the Alabama State Bar Executive Council, as persons of authority in the legal profession in Alabama, speak out now against Trump's depravity and lawlessness.
Thank very much.
Sincerely,
Rob Shattuck
Mountain Brook

Wednesday, January 14, 2026

Police departments protecting ICE protesters from violations of their rights

1/14/26 Email to Mountain Brook (AL) Mayor Smith and Police Chief Boulware
Using their office contact forms, I sent the below email to Mountain Brook (AL) Mayor Smith and Police Chief Boulware

Dear Mountain Brook Mayor Smith and Police Chief Boulware:
While this may not be relevant for Mountain Brook, I am suggesting for ICE protesters around the country that they request to meet with their police departments to discuss the rights of the people to protest ICE and to inquire of the police departments what the police departments will do and how they will do it in order to protect people from ICE violating the people's protest rights.
I intend to solicit Mountain Brook residents about whether they would like to meet with the Mountain Brook police department about this, if only for the purpose of signaling the concern of Mountain Brook residents about what ICE is doing around the country and that maybe the Mountain Brook police department will pass along to other Alabama police departments that residents in their jurisdictions may have similar concerns.
Thank you for your attention to this.
Sincerely,
Rob Shattuck
3812 Spring Valley Circle
(205) 967-5586

Proposed Huntsville City Council resolution
[Residents of Huntsville have submitted to the Huntsville City Council the below resolution for adoption by the City Council.]
RESOLUTION ON HUNTSVILLE IMMIGRATION ENFORCEMENT:
Whereas the City of Huntsville values its immigrant community and seeks to improve race relations to promote cooperative, peaceful existence and equality for the community; and
WHEREAS, the immigrant community is a major contributor to Huntsville’s dynamic economic, scientific, medical, and cultural growth; and
WHEREAS, the stated mission of the Huntsville Police Department is to serve our community by protecting life, liberty, property and defending the constitutional rights of all people with compassion, fairness, integrity, and professionalism; and
WHEREAS, the City Council recognizes the importance of protecting the safety, well-being, dignity, and Constitutional rights of all residents, including undocumented individuals; and
WHEREAS, the City of Huntsville seeks to ensure that all residents can access essential services without fear of deportation or discrimination; and
WHEREAS, local law enforcement agencies should focus on community safety and crime prevention rather than using valuable time and resources on enforcing federal immigration laws; and
WHEREAS, cooperation with ICE can lead to fear and mistrust within immigrant communities, discouraging individuals from reporting crimes or seeking assistance from law enforcement; and
WHEREAS, studies have shown that communities that foster trust between law enforcement and residents experience lower crime rates and improved public safety.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of Huntsville Alabama, that
1. The City of Huntsville shall not enter into any contract, agreement, or arrangement, such as the 287(g) program (8 U.S.C. § 1357(g)) that would grant federal civil immigration enforcement authority to its law enforcement officers.
2. The City of Huntsville shall not enter into any contract, agreement, or arrangement to detain or facilitate the detention of immigrants for federal immigration enforcement purposes.
3. The City of Huntsville shall implement training programs for local law enforcement personnel to ensure understanding of this resolution and to promote community policing practices that preserve Constitutional rights and build trust with all residents.
4. The City Council shall direct the Mayor to develop and implement policies that support this resolution and to report back to the City Council on the progress of these initiatives within six months.
5. This resolution shall take effect immediately upon its passage and approval. ADOPTED this [Insert Date] by the City Council of Huntsville Alabama.

1/15/26 Email I sent to Alabama Law Enforcement Agency using its website contact form
Re: Police departments protecting ICE protesters from violations of their rights
Using their office contact forms, I sent the below email to Mountain Brook Mayor Graham Smith and Police Chief Boulware:
Dear Mountain Brook Mayor Smith and Police Chief Boulware:
While this may not be relevant for Mountain Brook, I am suggesting for ICE protesters around the country that they request to meet with their police departments to discuss the rights of the people to protest ICE and to inquire of the police departments what the police departments will do and how they will do it in order to protect people from ICE violating the people's protest rights.
I intend to solicit Mountain Brook residents about whether they would like to meet with the Mountain Brook police department about this, if only for the purpose of signaling the concern of Mountain Brook residents about what ICE is doing around the country and that maybe the Mountain Brook police department will pass along to other Alabama police departments that residents in their jurisdictions may have similar concerns.
Thank you for your attention to this.
Sincerely,
Rob Shattuck
3812 Spring Valley Circle
(205) 967-5586
I think many Alabamians are concerned about how ICE is operating in America (including possibly in Alabama), and such Alabamians wish for local police departments to protect people wherever they are who are exercising their rights to protest ICE. 
I am sending this email to the Alabama Law Enforcement Agency for whatever assurances it may offer to Alabamians that law enforcement in Alabama will seek to protect Alabamians against ICE violating the rights of Alabamians to protest ICE.
Thank you.

Sunday, January 4, 2026

Getting AL TV stations to do better in 2026 elections

Email sent by a Facebook friend to Kerri Sutton, WVTM13 news director
From: 
Date: Fri, Jan 9, 2026 at 5:31 PM
Subject: 5:00 News re: Portland shooting
To: kerri.sutton@hearst.com <kerri.sutton@hearst.com>
Although I am generally pleased with your news reporting, I was very disappointed in the way you presented the shooting of the married couple in Portland, Oregon by border patrol agents. While no one knows yet exactly what happened, your reporting leads viewers to believe these people were dangerous criminals. But from the New York Times “The police were alerted to the shooting on Thursday when the injured man called 911, according to Bob Day, Portland’s police chief. The immigration agents involved in the shooting were no longer on the scene when local officers arrived.”
Immigration agents failed to inform anyone that they had shot and injured two people and instead fled, leaving these injured shooting victims to an unknown fate. And if these individuals were so dangerous, why did they not pursue an arrest?
Please do better.
Cordially,
_______________

Friday, January 2, 2026

Other states' lawyers, Trump and rule of law

Email North Carolina State Bar, North Carolina Bar Association and UNC School of Law student organizations (North Carolina Law Review, the Federalist Society, First Amendment Law Review, and Carolina Public Interest Law Organization)
From: Rob Shattuck <rdshatt@aol.com>
To: general@ncbar.gov <general@ncbar.gov>; kwilliams@belldavispitt.com <kwilliams@belldavispitt.com>; rharrington@rbh.com <rharrington@rbh.com>; nclrev@unc.edu <nclrev@unc.edu>; cpfraley@email.unc.edu <cpfraley@email.unc.edu>; falr@unc.edu <falr@unc.edu>; cgrill@unc.edu <cgrill@unc.edu>
Cc: fhelmsing@joneswalker.com <fhelmsing@joneswalker.com>; jeff@rbmattorneys.com <jeff@rbmattorneys.com>; terri.lovell@alabar.org <terri.lovell@alabar.org>; jana@janagarner.com <jana@janagarner.com>; rbell@maynardnexsen.com <rbell@maynardnexsen.com>; jc@strengthconnally.com <jc@strengthconnally.com>; wlee4@llln-law.com <wlee4@llln-law.com>; gparker@bradley.com <gparker@bradley.com>; roman.shaul@alabar.org <roman.shaul@alabar.org>; cbutler@dfhlaw.com <cbutler@dfhlaw.com>; ttp@manleytraegerlaw.com <ttp@manleytraegerlaw.com>; Devan@thebyrdfirm.com <devan@thebyrdfirm.com>; "devan@thebyrdfirm.com" <devan@thebyrdfirm.com>; chad.coker@alabar.org <chad.coker@alabar.org>
Sent: Friday, January 2, 2026 at 08:19:11 AM CST
Subject: North Carolina lawyers, Trump and the rule of law
To North Carolina State Bar, North Carolina Bar Association and UNC School of Law student organizations (North Carolina Law Review, the Federalist Society, First Amendment Law Review, and Carolina Public Interest Law Organization):
I am a retired Alabama lawyer who has been unable to budge the Alabama State Bar to speak up publicly about Trump and the rule of law. See Citizens Acting to End the Trump Presidency: The condition of the Department of Justice and its FBI and Citizens Acting to End the Trump Presidency: Alabama collaborator lawyers and Alabama resister lawyers.
I don't know the extent to which the North Carolina bar has spoken up publicly regarding Trump and the rule of law.
I hope the North Carolina bar has spoken up publicly regarding Trump and the rule of law.
If it has not, the purpose of this email is to urge such speaking up publicly.
Thank you.
Sincerely,
Rob Shattuck
Mountain Brook, AL